November 3, 2024
Athens, GR 21 C
Expand search form
Blog

Editorial: When a jury can’t make up its mind

Editorial: When a jury can’t make up its mind

The Joachim violin competition has a rotten record in producing winners.

Over 33 years, it has failed to deliver a world-conquering soloist. For several years, as we documented on slippedisc.com, the competition was dominated by two professor in favour of their students. Since the clean-up in 2018, it has struggled for world attention.

The best winners the competition has yielded are two outstanding concertmasters, Frank Huang (2000) and Robert Chen (1994).

The latest result is a new low.

Faced with two contenders of quite different merits, the jury threw up its hands and split the title. The audience had no trouble in deciding it preferred one over the other. What was so hard for the jury? Was someone rooting for a friend’s protege? Did they simply get tired and vote to go to bed?

A split result is a dereliction of jury duty. The administrator should have kept them locked in a room until a clearf result emerged.

The split outcome is bad for everyone. For the competition which emerges yet again without a credible result. For the jurors, who appear indecisive. And for the two winners who come away not with laurel wreaths but with a suggestion that they weren’t quite good enough to take the main prize.

There are no winners in Hanover.

The post Editorial: When a jury can’t make up its mind appeared first on Slippedisc.

Previous Article

Canadian half-wins the Joachim competition

Next Article

Can we still afford to pay live musicians?

You might be interested in …

Christian Thielemann drops out

Christian Thielemann drops out

The German conductor has withdrawan from two Bruckner 8s in Amsterdam next weekend. Concertgebouw Orchestra notice: Christian Thielemann has unfortunately had to cancel his performances with the Concertgebouw Orchestra due to illness. We are very […]

Germans pick conductor of the year

Germans pick conductor of the year

The Opus Klassik awards are out this morning. Unsurprisingly, the conductor of the year is the one with the most big jobs: Oslo, Paris, Amsterdam, Chicago. Instrumental winners are Isabelle Faust (violin), Gautier Capuçon (cello) […]

The ultimate refugee composer

The ultimate refugee composer

From the Lebrecht Album of the Week: Don’t try to pin an adjective to Gerhard: he transcends them all. The son of a Swiss-German father and an Alsatian mother, born in Spanish Catalonia, he studied […]