November 17, 2026
Athens, GR – 14 C
Expand search form
Blog

Well worth returning to Prague: under Lukáš Vasilek, Czech forces return to Honegger’s Jeanne d’Arc au bûcher following their iconic 1975 recording

Well worth returning to Prague: under Lukáš Vasilek, Czech forces return to Honegger's Jeanne d’Arc au bûcher following their iconic 1975 recording

Honegger: Jeanne d’Arc au bûcher; Audrey Bonnet, Sébastien Dutrieux, Czech Philharmonic, Prague Philharmonic Choir, Prague Philharmonic Children’s Choir, Lukáš Vasilek; Animal Music
Reviewed 15 November 2026

Honegger’s mystère lyrique returns to Prague for a recording with the same forces who created the 1975 recording. Here conductor Lukáš Vasilek brings impressive style and clarity to the work with wonderful declamation from a cast of French actors led by Audrey Bonnet

In 1949, Honegger conducted the Prague Philharmonic Choir in the Czech premiere of his oratorio Le Roi David (1921). In 1970, the Czech Philharmonic, conducted by Václav Neumann, performed Honegger’s dramatic oratorio Jeanne d’Arc au bûcher to mark the first anniversary of the death of Jan Palach, the Czech student who set himself on fire in protest against the 1968 Soviet occupation of Czechoslovakia. Five years later, in 1975, the Czech Philharmonic, Prague Philharmonic Choir, and Prague Philharmonic Children’s Choir, under Serge Baudo, recorded Jeanne d’Arc au bûcher for Supraphon, a recording that became iconic in raising the work’s profile.

Now, the Czech Philharmonic, Prague Philharmonic Choir and the Prague Philharmonic Children’s Choir have returned to Jeanne d’Arc au bûcher for a new recording on Animal Music under Lukáš Vasilek (Principal Conductor and Artistic Director of the Prague Philharmonic Choir) with Audrey Bonnet as Jeanne d’Arc and Sébastien Dutrieux as Frère Dominique. The recording is based on live performances given between 13-15 February 2025 at the Rudolfinum in Prague. The concerts marked not only Lukáš Vasilek’s debut conducting the Czech Philharmonic but the 55th anniversary of the work’s first performance at the Rudolfinum in 1970.

One of the key instigators of Jeanne d’Arc au bûcher was Ida Rubenstein (who took the role of Jeanne at the premiere) and the shape of Honegger’s work was partially dictated by Rubenstein’s talents (and limitations). Born into one of Russia’s richest families (in 1883) she was tall and striking looking, and took private dance lessons with Fokine. Her technique was such that Diaghilev would not allow her to dance leading roles but mime roles were created for her including the title role of Cléopâtre in the Paris season of 1909, and Zobéide in Scheherazade in 1910. 

In Paris, she developed a reputation as a diseuse and a number of hybrid works owe their origins to her, such as Gabriele d’Annunzio and Debussy’s Le Martyre de Saint Sébastien. It was Rubenstein’s idea to focus on Joan of Arc and she approached Honegger about creating a work that she could tour across France. After a false start, the words were entrusted to the poet Paul Claudel (who as ambassador to Brazil during World War I took Darius Milhaud as his secretary). Rubenstein would have to declaim the role, in fact she had worked as an actress in Russia (much to her family’s horror). Yet the idea of mixing speech and music was one that was hovering in the air.

Claudel had already worked with Milhaud on his L’Orestie d’Eschyle where the rhythm of the sung vocal parts was used to express the poetry. Honegger had collaborated with the poet Paul Valéry on the melodramas Amphion and Sémiramis both of which were created for Rubenstein. It was the question of how to fuse and integrate speech and music that rather drove the creation of Jeanne d’Arc for Claudel and Honegger, with the poet using a variety of devices from exclamations, onomatopoeia, free recitation, structured declamation, to singing.

The result is a work which is very much of its time yet which creates problems when brought into our modern world. For a start, it is worth bearing in mind that Rubenstein would have been reciting or declaiming without amplification, this brings a whole new sense to the spoken sections. Yet with the large forces that Honegger uses you wonder quite how Rubenstein (as Jeanne) and Jean Périer (as Dominique) coped in Basel at the premiere in 1938.

Recordings often combine spoken and musical in a way that sounds more like a radio play. If you want that, all well and good, but for a stylised piece like Jeanne d’Arc something different is required.

From the mysterious rumblings of the opening to the ecstatic closing passages it is clear that Lukáš Vasilek has the measure of the work. But what I really liked about the recording was the way the French actors really lean into the theatrical nature of the work. From the photographs of the performances in the booklet it is clear that individual microphones were used, yet the performance has a declaimed, theatrical quality to it. Perhaps it helps that the actors are Francophone and their delivery is all about the particular quality of declaimed French. The balance is admirable, this does not sound like a radio play but the voices are separated from the choir and orchestra. 

This clarity continues throughout the recording as Vasilek highlights the various building blocks of colour that Honegger uses, and never allows the layers to become muddy. He also brings out the surreal, hyper-dream-like quality of the work with its dramatic and aural juxtapositions. Audrey Bonnet gives a terrific performance, particularly in the final section. Throughout the smaller roles, both sung and spoken, are well taken.

Of course, to enjoy the piece you have to be able to settle into the idea of combining speech and music. Honegger’s orchestral passages merge into spoken drama in such a way that the two have an equal standing. Which means, of course, long passages of spoken French. It works well in live performance [I remember seeing David Temple conducting Crouch End Festival Chorus and Salmon Orchestra in the work with actors Mountview Theatre School and Jeanne Loriod on Ondes Martenot].

If you already have a recording of this fascinating work, then do not worry but the approach of this one makes it well worth hearing.

Arthur Honegger (1892 – 1955)
Jeanne d’Arc au bûcher, H 99 (1935/1944)
Dramatic oratorio (mystère lyrique) on a poem by Paul Claudel (1868 – 1955)

Spoken roles:
Audrey Bonnet / Jeanne d’Arc
Sébastien Dutrieux / Frère Dominique
Jean-Baptiste Le Vaillant / Hérault III, L’Âne, Jean de Luxembourg, Le Duc de Bedford, Heurtebise, Un Paysan
Thomas Gendronneau / Le Récitant, L’Appariteur, Regnault de Chartres, Guillaume de Flavy, Perrot, Le Clerc, Un Prêtre
Anna John Schmidtmajerová / La Mère aux Tonneaux

Sung roles:
Susanne Bernhard (soprano) / La Vierge
Veronika Rovná (soprano) / Marguerite
Anna Goryachova (mezzo-soprano) / Catherine
Kyle van Schoonhoven (tenor) / Porcus // tenor solo
Dovlet Nurgeldiyev (tenor) / Héraut I, Le Clerc
Zachary Altman (bass) / Héraut II // bass solo

Prague Philharmonic Choir
    Lukáš Vasilek – choirmaster
Prague Philharmonic Children‘s Choir
    Jiří Chvála, Petr Louženský – choirmasters
Czech Philharmonic
Lukáš Vasilek – conductor
Recorded live in the Rudolfinum, Prague, on 13-15 February, 2025
ANIMAL MUSIC ANI 153-2 [1:21:32]

Never miss out on future posts by following us

The blog is free, but I’d be delighted if you were to show your appreciation by buying me a coffee.

Elsewhere on this blog

  • Out Loud! director/choreographer William Byram on challenging the classical canon – interview
  • All-IN4Art with Aprile Millo – feature
  • Casting a spell: baritone Andrè Schuen & pianist Julius Drake in Schumann’s Heine settings at Temple Church for Temple Music – review
  • Not the end, but the beginning of a journey: Academy of St Martin in the Fields’ CEO Annie Lydford reflects on what the acquisition of The Warehouse could mean for the Orchestra – interview
  • Not what we expected: the new Tosca at ENO has compelling dramatic tension, creating one of the most gripping accounts I have seen in a long time – review
  • Charm & youthful engagement: Ellen Pearson & Laurence Kilsby join Nigel Foster to open the 2026 London Song Festival – concert review
  • La sonnambula: John Wilkie’s intelligent chamber account of Bellini’s opera for HGO benefitted from a glorious title role from Eyra Norman – review 
  • To capture the fullness of what choral singing is: composer Nathan James Dearden on his debut album, i breathe – interview
  • Home

Go to Source article

Previous Article

Carmen with Opera North, Gabrieli Roar with young people from Cleethorpes, Corby, London, Northampton and Skegness, and more at the 2027 Nevill Holt Festival

Next Article

Children can’t choose something they’re not offered: the Richard Shephard Music Foundation’s 2025/26 impact report

You might be interested in …

Three new recruits in the Boston Symphony

Three new recruits in the Boston Symphony

The orchestra, with music director Andris Nelsons, has added Samuel Andonian and Arianna Brusubardis Grace to its violin section. Both are local youngesters. Caleb Quillen (pictured) of the Dallas Symphony Orchestra succeeds Ed Barker as […]

Korean tops Apple streaming

Korean tops Apple streaming

This week’s #1 is Yunchan Lim with … not his finest hour. But the fans are out in force. Here’s the Apple top ten exclusive to slippedisc.com. 1 Tchaikovsky: The Seasons Yunchan Lim 2 Beethoven […]

At last, the Real Meistersinger

At last, the Real Meistersinger

Richard Wagner’s only comic opera had a long gestation. Summer 1845: drawing on the History of German Literature as well as the biography of poet and shoemaker Hans Sachs, the composer sketches out ideas for a satirical […]