![]() |
| Monteverdi: L’incoronazione di Poppea – Anna Dennis, Ed Lyon, Laurence Cummings – Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen] |
Monteverdi: L’incoronazione di Poppea; Anna Dennis, Ed Lyon, Katie Bray, Christopher Lowrey, Nahuel Di Pierro, Stuart Jackson, Maryam Wocial, Academy of Ancient Music, Laurence Cummings; Barbican Hall
Reviewed 17 November 2026
An admirably full version of the score in a performance with real dramatic flow that gripped from beginning to end with individual performances of great style, creating something of an operatic highlight for this year
That Monteverdi’s L’incoronazione di Poppea survives at all must be regarded as something of a miracle. We have score for three of his large-scale operas but five others do not survive. Opera scores were working tools to be used and abused in the theatre and then presumably discarded. This was a culture where opera was continually renewed, librettos reset by other composers and revival was rare.
This means that our knowledge of the development of Monteverdi’s large-scale dramatic skill jumps from Orfeo (written for lavish forces for a ducal wedding in Mantua in 1607) to Il ritorno d’Ulisse (1640) and L’incoronazione di Poppea (1642/43), both of which written for the commercial theatre in Venice using far from lavish instrumental forces.
What survives is an early Venetian score and another score derived from a revival in Naples in 1651. This latter is remarkable in itself as revivals were rare, and the Neapolitan score has material added to suit local tastes. There are also libretti along with librettist Busenello’s final printed libretto (which dates from 1656). None of the above agree, which probably reflects the dynamic nature of an opera at the time, particularly as more than one hand is detected in the music (it is surmised that the elderly Monteverdi had help from pupils). The scores themselves are spare, reflecting the freedom that performers received. All this means that when bringing the work to the modern stage, music directors have a lot of decisions to make.
![]() |
| Monteverdi: L’incoronazione di Poppea – Katie Bray – Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen] |
Laurence Cummings and the Academy of Ancient Music performed Monteverdi’s L’incoronazione di Poppea at the Barbican Hall on 17 November 2026 (having previously performed the work in Venice the previous weekend). Ed Lyon was Nerone and Anna Dennis was Ottavia, with Katie Bray as Ottavia, Christopher Lowrey as Ottone, Nahuel Di Pierro as Seneca, Stuart Jackson as Arnalta and Maryam Wocial as Drusilla.
Cummings used a very full version of the score: all the gods, the scenes with Valletto and Damigella, the full coronation scene. There were 21 named roles in all, plus the Coro dei Famigliari (Seneca’s followers), Consuls and Tribunes (at the coronation), and the Coro d’Amori, which meant there was a reasonable amount of doubling. A tenor (Ed Lyon) was cast as Nerone rather than a female mezzo-soprano (instead of Monteverdi’s soprano castrato), with a countertenor (Christopher Lowrey) as Ottone (instead of Monteverdi’s alto castrato). A high tenor (Stuart Jackson) was Arnalta rather than a contralto as is often the case (Monteverdi probably used a female contralto but tenors playing older women was very much a 17th century operatic thing). The orchestra used a string section of seven, plus two theorbos and harp, plus Ashok Gupta doubling harpsichord and organ, and Laurence Cummings directing from the harpsichord.
Regarding the doublings, Katie Bray sang Ottavia and La Virtu (which is a logical pairing). But Anna Dennis did not sing La Fortuna (another logical pairing with Poppea), instead Danni O’Neill sang La Fortuna, Pallade and Damigella, whilst Rachel Redmond was both mother and son, singing Amore and Venere. One other notable piece of casting, mezzo-soprano Fiona Kimm was Nutrice; Kimm’s career has spanned some 50 years and she has been a presence in this opera on several other occasions.
![]() |
| Monteverdi: L’incoronazione di Poppea – Maryam Wocial, Fiona Kimm — Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen] |
The work was semi-staged, we had entrances and exits, characters talked and interacted with each other. Though the singers carried scores, these were used sparingly and most sang their major moments from memory. The result concentrated on the creation of character, there was no extraneous action; so the stage was empty for the coronation scene apart from Venere (Rachel Redmond) and the chorus (everybody else). The women wore glamorous concert dress (two outfits for Rachel Redmond) with the men in concert black, though Ed Lyon’s Nerone cut a seriously stylish dash. As Arnalta (a female character), Stuart Jackson accessorised his concert-black with a flowery scarf and a selection of aprons. Maryam Wocial’s Drusilla wore a lavish cloak so that when Christopher Lowrey’s Ottone disguised himself, he lost his dashing, patterned jacket and wore Wocial’s cloak; a neat solution.
The original venue for the opera, the Teatro Santi Giovanni e Paolo in Venice, was small, seating around 900 audience members (or perhaps less), and Monteverdi’s opera is dialogue heavy. The result would have been more like a sung play than a grand operatic spectacle. This means that pacing the work in a modern concert hall can be tricky.
Under Laurence Cummings’ deft direction, the performance at the Barbican had real dramatic flow. There were no pauses between scenes and the whole had real impetus, with the running time coming in at around three hours (including interval). The drama gripped from beginning to end and the various short scenes including those for the gods and for the comic characters added to the dramatic impetus rather than impeding it. This was one of those performances of L’incoronazione di Poppea that really caught the work’s essence for a modern day audience.
![]() |
| Monteverdi: L’incoronazione di Poppea – Anna Dennis, Stuart Jackson — Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen] |
Anna Dennis made a very stylish Poppea, singing with fine elegance of line and real intensity. This Poppea could scheme with the best of them and was very sensual with Ed Lyon’s Nerone, but there was also a real feeling for the music. Rather less skittish than usual, she brought real poise to the role. It helped that her scenes with Ed Lyon really crackled, so you believed in the two as a couple.
Lyon sang Nerone’s musical line with real focus and elegance. If you have to have Nerone sung by a tenor (and I understand the dramatic logic) then you could not hope for a better account of the role. Lyon’s voice lacked the upfront aural sensuality a mezzo-soprano might bring, but what he gave us was moments of real beauty of tone, incredible engagement with Dennis’s Poppea, and a feeling of virility. Allied to this, his outbursts of temper (of which Nerone has plenty) had a real anger to them, this Nerone was dangerous.
After a sober and telling account of La Virtu’s solo in the prologue, Katie Bray made a vivid and rather intense Ottavia. There was a strength to Bray’s performance along with a powerful feeling of character allied to wonderful attention to the words. Every syllable counted, and this Ottavia could really spit words out. Bray gave Ottavia a tragic intensity without the grandeur some singers have brought to the role. Her opening and closing solo scenes were powerful indeed, but in between Bray made Ottavia’s scheming wonderfully intense, creating a character that you would not have dreamed of messing with!
![]() |
| Monteverdi: L’incoronazione di Poppea – Maryam Wocial, Laurence Cummings, Christopher Lowrey — Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen] |
The problem with having a tenor singing Nerone is that the contrast of register and voice type between tenor and countertenor can make Ottone come over as effete and ineffectual. Indeed the character does dither rather a lot, after all our first sight of him is standing outside his lover’s house. Christopher Lowrey managed to reduce Ottone’s idiot-quotient and Lowrey’s often touching performance made us rather sympathetic to Ottone’s dilemmas. This was particularly true in Act Three, when Lowrey was terrific as he psyched himself up to do Ottavia’s billing (Katie Bray in devastating form here),
All this meant that we did feel sorry for Marym Wocial’s Drusilla. Wocial is still at the Royal College of Music (at the International Opera Studio), but her vivid performance as Drusilla, by turns carefree and tragic, seems to promise a terrific career ahead.
Arnalta is a contradiction. A minor character who gets two solos; a comic character who sings one of the most touching lyric moments in the opera (the Act Two lullaby). Stuart Jacksons brought heroic tone and comic timing to the role, creating a rather fey man-servant figure, with vivid intensity in the upper register yet tenderness in the lullaby.
As the other female servant, Nutrice, Fiona Kimm combined both gravitas and comic timing. She made the most of her injunction to Ottavia to go and get a lover (and Katie Bray’s face her in reaction was priceless), yet Kimm was wonderfully lively in the dialogue with Rory Carver’s Valletto and Danni O’Neill’s Damigella. These latter two were a complete delight as their vivid, carefree scene together made the right counterpoint to the intensity of Nerone and Poppea’s relationship. Elsewhere, Carver’s Valletto might not have set Seneca’s (Nahuel Di Pierro) beard alight but his solo had real edge. O’Neill had opened proceedings with as a self-important La Fortuna, and she popped up later as Pallade. Nahuel Di Pierro might not have had a voice with gravelly lower reaches, but he had real dignity as Seneca, going to his death with sober gravitas and warm tone.
![]() |
| Monteverdi: L’incoronazione di Poppea – Rory Carver (Valletto), Danni O’Neill (Damigella) – Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen] |
As Lucano, Thomas Walker matched Ed Lyon’s Nerone note for note in their thrillingly vivid duet. Elsewhere Walker was a serio-comic solider. Rory Carver was the other solider, having a nice double act with Walker, as well as doubling as Valletto, plus being on of Senega’s Famigliari. Richard Latham was Liberto, with Robert MacDonald as Littore and a resonant Mercurio sung from the auditorium. The four, Walker, Carver, Latham and MacDonald, formed the chorus of Consuls and Tribunes in the coronation scene. Rachel Redmond was a cheeky Amore, whose antics are essential to the plot in Act Two, and then reappeared as a poised Venere.
The instrumental ensemble kept things sprightly whilst giving due space for Monteverdi’s touching melodic moments. A bit shout out must go to the continuo group – Reiko Ichise (viola da gamba), William Carter and Kristiina Watt (theorbo), Joy Smith (harp), Ashok Gupta (harpsichord and organ), Laurence Cummings (harpsichord) – who made the continuo accompaniment to the dialogue always alert and varied.
Whilst evil does not exactly triumph in the opera, there is a sense that the ‘bad girl’ (Poppea) wins. This makes L’incoronazione di Poppea relatively unusual in the operatic canon. Into the early 18th century bad girls did win (Medea escapes at the end of Handel’s Teseo and Agrippina triumphs in Handel’s opera). But by the middle of the century, with the strong commoditisation of opera, it was clear – ‘bad girls’ die at the end. Something that did not really change until the 20th century. Monteverdi emphasises this win not by giving us a triumphant final duet but instead a completely ravishing yet intimate one. Dennis and Lyon really made the heart sing here, relishing the music’s expressive dissonances and accompanied by only a handful of musicians. You could have heard a pin drop at the end.
![]() |
| Monteverdi: L’incoronazione di Poppea – Anna Dennis, Ed Lyon — Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen] |
L’incoronazione di Poppea might be a masterpiece but it does not perform itself. The structure can feel somewhat discursive to our modern stage; more Shakespearean than 19th-century opera with its focus on a couple of characters. Here, presented in its fullest form, Laurence Cummings and his team brought a vivid elan to the individual characters whilst Cummings knitted the mosaic of characters and styles into a profoundly satisfying whole.
The blog is free, but I’d be delighted if you were to show your appreciation by buying me a coffee.
Elsewhere on this blog
- Out Loud! director/choreographer William Byram on challenging the classical canon – interview
- All-IN4Art with Aprile Millo – feature
- Casting a spell: baritone Andrè Schuen & pianist Julius Drake in Schumann’s Heine settings at Temple Church for Temple Music – review
- Not the end, but the beginning of a journey: Academy of St Martin in the Fields’ CEO Annie Lydford reflects on what the acquisition of The Warehouse could mean for the Orchestra – interview
- Not what we expected: the new Tosca at ENO has compelling dramatic tension, creating one of the most gripping accounts I have seen in a long time – review
- Charm & youthful engagement: Ellen Pearson & Laurence Kilsby join Nigel Foster to open the 2026 London Song Festival – concert review
- La sonnambula: John Wilkie’s intelligent chamber account of Bellini’s opera for HGO benefitted from a glorious title role from Eyra Norman – review
- Home


![Monteverdi: L'incoronazione di Poppea - Anna Dennis, Ed Lyon, Laurence Cummings - Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen] Monteverdi: L'incoronazione di Poppea - Anna Dennis, Ed Lyon, Laurence Cummings - Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen]](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjH6PnD50CTzwZqjD15O4ljhTKEPh8Tz4H7mWGvRggfDARmCfB9-5t-VYRcrVq00IwjnIc2kSUNerrRtDwY7PHcCahfFF4qMHOByB-8m0HXBWjyfrDTDkiQoOJaOrhM_BBTJE-mmqEkOs0Lokt9a9gzMOzU_41DqOiBXt62v0WnDQ66gT2qEPpg_Q/w640-h426/AAM L'incoronazione%20di%20Poppea%2012%20credit%20Mark%20Allen.jpg)
![Monteverdi: L'incoronazione di Poppea - Katie Bray - Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen] Monteverdi: L'incoronazione di Poppea - Katie Bray - Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen]](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEi1HU6d1No5OsAB_Qz-2HNYp7I95_ywYFQYUwB22552JPmHBLykhPlp0wEJBBNUEkVBKBJSlgGrAuDYC0Frerr5GwJD3_JT6IInlujUVvQwkI2EFJh0DoPLpVZkuSnuPdAWD7c3v4-oUul143hJyzNX5d0GAURh9mo2HrlmuQH1fr0rwyyy1kqIFQ/w640-h426/AAM L'incoronazione%20di%20Poppea%2006%20credit%20Mark%20Allen.jpg)
![Monteverdi: L'incoronazione di Poppea - Maryam Wocial, Fiona Kimm -- Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen] Monteverdi: L'incoronazione di Poppea - Maryam Wocial, Fiona Kimm -- Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen]](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhC9LssOQLihVRt_2D3-6YSA8gu9m50gAU-hvlL1o5EfCgLmwoiDs-rXdyXs4Ml32obkFK2MasOdzn8JhZ98REF05QymGEvpyICwlsywynGVfQ9E8QkAHzhxHWpUuLZoRLL_nwYLZ3DQYgYDfusIyhyZByndknax_ikve2cuZsYkohElnT785XRbg/w640-h426/AAM L'incoronazione%20di%20Poppea%2010%20credit%20Mark%20Allen.jpg)
![Monteverdi: L'incoronazione di Poppea - Anna Dennis, Stuart Jackson -- Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen] Monteverdi: L'incoronazione di Poppea - Anna Dennis, Stuart Jackson -- Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen]](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEieKH8TbntwckbhDr2YM3jJ94iuRMy0KG2FwLvFrE7Yy09t3xcjyP6iQC9j8OcZohUKu4FEFp4xkq4DlInsi2gKips5qovU4d20MhVyfpPq1cpyV3F5kJUbOMH8Vs0TtTaLW39Q3f1ydoyuHIMHlgCQQFJo008NM2c8Y1-B0vKzgz1bqwvnaAgSLA/w640-h426/AAM L'incoronazione%20di%20Poppea%2011%20credit%20Mark%20Allen.jpg)
![Monteverdi: L'incoronazione di Poppea - Maryam Wocial, Laurence Cummings, Christopher Lowrey -- Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen] Monteverdi: L'incoronazione di Poppea - Maryam Wocial, Laurence Cummings, Christopher Lowrey -- Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen]](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhqGrnroZFiqQGFUq_LXjn8i_0ASCI06YBZtad0R10Nzqj-nGbCB6BgR2OP8buo2l1I5o1vqrocuaskBa-F9TVPqzdQZrvDPXZywlJjtwrTO5dUI_ge1ZyFd7vo_6Xn0SClwetBqRNkzywkmTG22H2PoqLUiM9KOWYpeRX8xiTiMwUo8b_HEXGNWw/w640-h426/AAM L'incoronazione%20di%20Poppea%2008%20credit%20Mark%20Allen.jpg)
![Monteverdi: L'incoronazione di Poppea - Rory Carver, Danni O'Neill -- Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen] Monteverdi: L'incoronazione di Poppea - Rory Carver, Danni O'Neill -- Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen]](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhjDW5787ctvZKRzubb-oqv61xKG9Ojd0VvZf9MCzXvKkt7ohR4DZMBp2y9pkIhbA3DQ_pQ4X6lpgmt8NfjiZIbuR7sRPt-C8nO0ZXy12T_vrxuzVw1u2F7lGqJ6R4xL2vvD-Ca0pWC7C8ctED90Yx-K5MV8dl-kLDnbDrUtyyl03zaF2L6ZYlBfA/w640-h422/AAM L'incoronazione%20di%20Poppea%2003%20credit%20Mark%20Allen.jpg)
![Monteverdi: L'incoronazione di Poppea - Anna Dennis, Ed Lyon -- Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen] Monteverdi: L'incoronazione di Poppea - Anna Dennis, Ed Lyon -- Academy of Ancient Music, Barbican [Photo: Mark Allen]](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEj_3_kS6mKyMS987qQmreLYyjiSihRDHDxZHykBcK6rUz88BOjIuZHjc6qGP9qLKJZJoGJdE7emi05L3B8CU0_S4dNiGEKZLBSCvgGN_A7dSqgzK-xETSXFN3t-m4C0qT88whXxQ76hn4Tzc_fd_KgNrxgWbEIyX0hawolUr7jZDB0afRmvHq3FUA/w640-h428/AAM L'incoronazione%20di%20Poppea%2013%20credit%20Mark%20Allen.jpg)
