November 20, 2026
Athens, GR – 14 C
Expand search form
Blog

a light exists: Kaprálová, Berg, Klein, Barber & Carter

a light exists: Kaprálová, Berg, Klein, Barber & Carter
a light exists: Kaprálová, Berg, Klein, Barber & Carter

Released October 30, this is a fascinating programme. the lower-cased a light exists puts together music by Kapralová, Berg, Gideon Klein, Barber and Elliot Carter, as heady a mix as one is likely to find. The pieces tend towards the composers’ early output (necessarily in the case of the short-lived Kaprálová and Klein).

And no wonder the title is lower case (at least on the front cover) – it comes from a poem by Emily Dickinson, A Light Exists in Spring.

Vítězslava Kapralová (1915-40) achieved so much in her short life – she died of tuberculosis. She, at age 22, was the first woman to conduct the Czech Philharmonic. We have here her four Dubovná Preludia (April Preludes), originally written for the great Rudolf Firkušný. She was living in Paris at he time (April in Paris?), and sometimes we hear the soft light of Parisian harmony; and yet the primary sense of is the strength of the Czech homeland, perhaps owing something to Janäček: try first movement, Allegro ma non troppo, with its folkish slant, or the simplicity of the opening of the third:

The finale perhaps conveys the playfulness of Spring, a sort of acidic frolicking:

… but for me, it is the stasis and beauty of the second movement an Andante, that is so touching, especially w=given Evan Mitchell’s sensitive pianism:

Occasionally, there are harmonies which tend towards Messiaen even. A fascinating experience.


Berg’s Piano Sonata is much better-known – it is also his Op. 1, and has two sharps as it’s key signature – which allows for B-Minor, used as more of a structural articulator than firm key centre. Strong cadences in the “home key” appear at salient moments – the opening, the end of the exposition, the powerful climax – while whirling chromaticism pervades in between. Voice-leading is a primary method of creating sense and architecture – polyphony is masterly deployed. Evan Mitchell understands the structure well, too:

It makes a fine contrast to the spikiness of Gideon Klein’s Piano Sonata first movement: and yet, as the music moves towards lyricism there are distinct parallel in methodology, not least terracing of material. Mitchell’s clarity is most laudable here, with fine staccato for chords:

Klein was a composer whose life was tragically cut short – he was one of the composers at Theriesenstadt. The Adagio is a glistening dream and again there are parallels with the Berg, melodic shapes this time as well as related harmonic structures:

A feisty finale satisfyingly ends the sonata;


Barber’s Interlude is exactly that – it has a parenthesised subtitle, “Adagio for Jeanne,” and the first of two posthumously-published interludes . It was written while Barber was a student at Curtis, and is shot through with lyricism. Again, there are parallels back to the Berg, here in some of the left-hand writing, but it carries individuality, certainly, and there are some dcscents that are pure Barber. Th use of harmony also points forward to later works by this composer.

The Elliott Carter Piano Sonata i(1945-6) s the thorniest work here, but again Mitchell finds its core lyricism within the first movement (Maestoso) which blossoms in the final Andante – where a certain playfulness lies and, in so appearing, brings in nods to Americana. Elsewhere, there is a shadow of Prokofiev. This is such a persuasive performance of this early work (the later Night Fantasies for piano is far better known): on its own, it makes the disc recommendable.

Mitchell is a powerful Carter advocate. To expand Carter listening, try Pina Napoletano’s recording of the Night Fantasies and Two Thoughts about the Piano on Odradek (coupled with Beethoven’s final two sonatas, and Jeremy Mumford’s Elliott Carter Tributes: subscribers can find my review in Fanfare, issue 44:2, Nov/Dec 2020). Although if it is stimulating couplings you’re after, Peter Sievewright on Divine Art performs it alongside Miklos Rósza’s Piano Sonata and MacDowell’s Piano Sonata No. 4 in E-Minor, “Keltic” (again reviewed in Fanfare by myself, 35:3, Jan.Feb 2012).

Two performances on disc that raise their heads here are those by Paul Jacobs and Charles Rosen, complementary in the juxtaposition of Jacobs’ sense of freedom against Rosen’s rigour. Mitchell is a middle way, allowing for lyricism while always honouring the process..

The disc is available at Amazon here.


Go to Source article

Previous Article

The Geneva Competition at 80, Composition and Conducting: Conducting

You might be interested in …

Fame school principal dies, 94

Fame school principal dies, 94

Richard Klein, principal of New York’s High School of Music and Art, has died, aged 94. He unified two schools in 1984, creating Fiorello H. LaGuardia High School of Music and Art and the Performing […]